Thanks to all for your replies and suggestions. This is definitely the right forum for all things Negril. I will look into Moonrise Villa and Villa Mora - 2 places I had not even heard of. Unfortunately Marko, Coral Seas is on the expensive side wanting $92 a night at that time of the year, but thank you.
I am still warm on the idea of Greenleaf Cabins and Miss Norma's Rooms but with the latter I might be extremely lonely (ahh poor me).

Thanks once again