My wife and I stayed at Sunset in 2005. We loved it. But, we didn't do much at the resort itself....other than eat several great lobster dinners next to the pool. We went on several day trips from there, and over to a beach area nearby. Kory South and his staff were super! Jakes gets all of the hype, but they are very pricey. So, with Sunset you are right next door to Jakes and not far from Jack Sprats.
Back then a lot of the beaches had been eroded from the storms....it should be better now. But there was a nice beach down the road.
Check out treasurebeach.net. Great site with a map and a forum for asking questions. We hired a great, safe older Rasta named Ranni as our driver. He took us on several day trips and to the airport.
If you have any questions, pm me.