First stay in 98 was Samsara. It was booked through Sears in Canada and included a 25 dollar per week bar credit and an air equipped room with breakfast included.
Loved it. Loved the grounds and the nicest person we met at the hotel was the groundskeeper; Melvin.
Free daily transfers to Legends and back was a big selling point.
The next trip we decided to go all-inclusive at Trelawny Beach Resort which I believe was a "Starfish" branded resort at the time.
We had a great time, but the beach was always windy and more choppy than Negril. Visited Falmouth and loved it. Left my bank card in the machine and had people chasing me down the road to return it. They wouldn't accept a reward.
That last 8 visits have been to Seastar Inn on the west end (best end).
Chris and Francine are the best hosts in the parish and the hotel has some of the best vibes on the island. No need for us to go anywhere else; but if I couldn't find space at the popular Seastar, I would stay at Rhodes Hall with their wonderful infinity pool and spectacular setting.