We have stayed at both the GP and The Mariposa several times. With about 20 people coming, most of all of them are Jamica virgins, I feel that the atmosphere of a smaller AI would be a hit with most. With the October prices for a week there, it also fits into most budgets. I haven't made the call to the GP yet for bookings yet but will in the next week. Most likely will be going down in February. Peace!