We have done the split stay, did Catcha for one night ( yes they do single nights) and had Sagi, one of the best cottages I have ever stayed at then went to the beach for 13 nights. Next reach we are doing Ochi for 4 nights, Catcha (Sagi again!) for 2nights and then CSA for 11 nights to change it up. We are beach people as well, walking each day. Wife isn't a strong swimmer so I worry about to much time on the cliffs. I on the other hand love to jump from the highest peak at Catcha and over at Ricks. Try it for at least one night!