Depends a lot on your personal must haves. HSH with taxes on the sale rate is $85, adding on the $20/night fridge rental brings it to $105. Coffee pot rental was another $10/day. I can bring my own travel coffee maker but prefer not to...a fridge is another story and essential IMO. As long as I have breakfast at my hotel, I prefer to eat at other cliff places the rest of the day (that's partly why I want to stay on the cliffs, closer access to all the eateries I've yet to try). I like to self serve my own drinks on hotel property, so works better if they don't have a bar. As long as there's good places to eat/drink next door or across the street and the location is otherwise good, with wifi and fridge (bonus for coffee pot!), my priorities are met. For others, a bar and restaurant may be must haves. For my priorities and cost factor, I chose Mirage over HSH. Catcha Gardens would have been great with their sale price, but room sea view was my first priority for this stay.