Bentley's is not open so that narrows it down. I suggest Sips 'n Bites, about 1.25 km towards Negril downtown from Banana Shout. Plain local restaurant with great local food (brown stew chicken with sides was delish), very reasonably priced. They are closed on Saturdays though. They don't serve alcohol but have heard you can bring your own. A must try for good local food IMO.