We had dinner there once towards the end of our last trip. Sea was rough, and a storm was coming in so the upstairs was closed. Dinner was decent, but I was also surprised at the low number of visitors there... I had chalked it up to going at the end of November and the weather that day.

My wife loves the ice cream though... I think my buddy and I spent over $100 on ice cream over the 10 days we were there for him, his wife and my wife. I have yet to even try it!