BethAnn...since you're needing to go outside of the "resilient corridor" it seems arriving as a Category 4 would be the best/easiest for you both.
If you're both fully vaccinated you'll only need a negative PCR test done "within 3 days of departure to Jamaica" and you won't have to quarantine upon arrival.

Further info below...
https://www.visitjamaica.com/travela...er-categories/