I've taken this tour a couple of times, last time w/ newbies a few years ago. It's interesting, they loved it. It was in conjunction w/ a visit to YS Falls, my personal favorite. Falls first, then Appleton. I suppose you could also add Pelican bar to the day but that might make for a long day. I've also done YS, Appleton, Lover's Leap - which I've read is now closed. It probably also depends on your alcohol intake. At the end of the Appleton tour you can sample away from the many offerings of rums they make. At the start you'll be served the strongest rum punch I've ever had in JA. It is a fun day.