"I just disagree that tipping is the most efficient or even a credible way to promote change."

What does leaving a tip or service charge have to do with promoting change...It is not up to us to promote change in Jamaica. i have seen too much outside influence in Jamaica in the last 20 years promoting change. It is their country and they let us visit as guest...WE all have a choice to go to one of those countries you speak of that does not have to count on a tip to not go home hungry..."I believe in fiscal responsibility" As far as fiscal responsibility here is my take...I spend most of my life managing fiscal responsibility and for two weeks out of the year I take some time off....Most of the places I dine at don't add tax or service charge...It is simply 300 J for a small box lunch or 500 for the large box...My hotel does add service charge which is split up between all employees on the property...I add a daily bump for my housekeeper, beach attendant, chef and a couple of bucks every time I get food brought to my room....I don't know if there is any connection but i always get my room done early while I am at breakfast, I get a good spot on the beach, i get an extra piece of fish on my plate and when I order food in my room I get it really fast.....Give respect and you get respect....at least it works for me....