hey JahLove, wifey and I stayed there a few years ago... there were certainly some pros n cons...

PROS:

inexpensive
location on the west end
cute n quaint cottage
loved their dogs
one late night wifey was super mad (well just drunk n hungry really), the owner Jeannie overheard us and walked over with a tuna fish sandwich! So kind of her, we got a laugh because out of anything in this world- wifey hates tuna fish.. but she chowed this one right down- no problem! hahaha
kind of cool staying 'up a lane' in more of a neighborhood atmosphere
cottage is way larger than any room we've ever stayed at in negril
comfy hammock
close to Bella Donnas- they host reggae shows there so it was nice to hear the music form the porch and head over
in the cottage- there was a bottle of rum cream and a big submarine samwich wating for us
kind of cool staying in a cottage... you can easily picture what life would be like living on the island (as opposed to an ocean view suite)

CONS:

there were several mornings waking up to their dogs barking at passerby goats
lost a pair of shoes to the dogs (our bad though- we were warned)
one morning a huge centipede thingy was in our shower... come to find out they are super poisoness
the gate doesnt open that easily sober let alone drizzunk... the neighbor came over and help us with it a couple times hahaha
the water ran out with about 3 days left of our stay. I could go without it just fine, but wifey not so much. we had to use the outdoor showers at negril escape

Name:  stoney.jpg
Views: 446
Size:  99.2 KB

Name:  stoney2.jpg
Views: 436
Size:  99.0 KB

Name:  stoney3.jpg
Views: 437
Size:  102.9 KB

I hope this helps you make your decision.
Let me know if you have any other questions that I can help with,
-murph